Classement des plateformes de signalement pour la France sous la Loi Waserman et Sapin II. Barème fixe de 25 critères ; chaque score est justifié par une preuve.
Outils notés
12
Base max
50
Bonus France max
8
Version du barème
v2
Sur les 12 plateformes évaluées au regard de Loi Waserman, EthicsPortal se classe première avec 54 points sur 58, devant Whispli à 40.
La France est l’un des rares marchés de l’UE où le bonus pays change vraiment le classement. Un simple discours « conforme à la directive européenne » ne suffit pas : les acheteurs veulent savoir si l’éditeur comprend la Loi Waserman, si Sapin II reste dans le périmètre pour les grandes organisations, et si le produit tient la route dans un cycle d’achat français.
Cette édition combine donc deux couches :
le barème de base sur 50 points, agnostique au pays, qui mesure la qualité produit, la posture sécurité, la transparence tarifaire et la profondeur workflow ;
le modificateur France sur 8 points, qui récompense le cadrage explicite Waserman / Sapin II, l’interface en français et, quand elle est publiée clairement, une option de résidence des données en France.
Le résultat pénalise deux échecs fréquents du marché français : les produits locaux anciens, bien cadrés juridiquement mais faibles en profondeur produit, et les produits globaux solides techniquement mais presque muets sur le droit français.
Sydney, Australia (offices in Paris and Boston) · Enterprise whistleblowing, disclosure, hotline, and investigation platform operating in 60+ countries.
40 / 58
Base 32 · Bonus 8 · Niveau P
Legal
9/16
Reporter
9/10
Handler
7/10
Security
7/8
Commercial
0/6
Forces
France-specific public content names Loi Waserman and compares it with Sapin 2.
Product pages support 70+ languages, Safe Inbox, web/mobile/email/QR/Voice AI intake, configurable workflows, SLAs, retention, routing, and audit logs.
Security, product and pricing pages support ISO 27001, SOC 2 Type II, customer-managed encryption keys, selectable hosting regions including France and Germany, API/integrations, 2FA, SSO, and penetration testing.
Faiblesses
Pricing amounts, self-serve trial, exact EU official-language coverage, subprocessor objection mechanics, and article-by-article Directive mapping were not disclosed on public pages reviewed.
The previous /solutions/whistleblower/ and /whispli-pricing/ URLs were not usable current evidence.
Point distinctif
Whispli publishes France-specific legal framing and security architecture for a sales-led enterprise product.
Copenhagen, Denmark · Whistleblower Software product from Formalize with public Core and Advanced annual pricing.
39 / 58
Base 32 · Bonus 7 · Niveau P
Legal
8/16
Reporter
7/10
Handler
7/10
Security
6/8
Commercial
4/6
Forces
Each locale of the marketing site names its own transposition law, including Loi Waserman (Sapin II) in French, Law 4990/2022 in Greek, Ley 2/2023 in Spanish and HinSchG in German.
The product page documents two-way anonymous messaging, file upload, voice reporting, automatic case delegation and deadline reminders.
Security page names ISO 27001:2022, ISAE 3000 Type 2, ENS Alta, WCAG 2.1 AA, a June 2024 penetration test, end-to-end encryption and AWS Frankfurt hosting.
Faiblesses
No named sub-processor list, no downloadable DPA and no right-to-object mechanism; the personal data policy states only that sub-processors exist and that some are in third countries.
API access, DPIA support, reporter return-access mechanism and Directive article-level mapping were not disclosed on public pages reviewed.
Retention is a vendor-set 3 years after subscription termination, not per-organisation configurable purge.
Point distinctif
The July review read only the English pages and scored France and Greece at 1 of 8 and 1 of 6 for laws the vendor names on its own French and Greek sites; re-reading the locale sites moved the two country bonuses by 10 points and the base by 5.
Sweden · Whistleblowing module inside Euronext Corporate Solutions' ComplyLog compliance suite, with ISO 27001-certified infrastructure positioning.
36 / 58
Base 33 · Bonus 3 · Niveau P
Legal
12/16
Reporter
7/10
Handler
7/10
Security
7/8
Commercial
0/6
Forces
Public product detail covers statuses, reminders, permissions, and communication
2025 ComplyLog factsheet adds GDPR role clarity, EEA storage, ISO/IEC 27001, encryption, access logging, retention, and DPA/sub-processor disclosures
Product page and factsheet support anonymous case handling, written/audio reports, and EU Whistleblowing Directive positioning
Faiblesses
No explicit public Waserman or Sapin II framing found
Pricing is not published publicly
Reporter return-access mechanism and append-only audit guarantees are not fully documented publicly
Point distinctif
IntegrityLog has moved under the Euronext Corporate Solutions surface; the most detailed current evidence comes from the 2025 ComplyLog privacy factsheet rather than a France-law sales page.
Munich, Germany · Whistleblowing module of the EQS Compliance COCKPIT with Essential, Professional, and Enterprise packages. EQS acquired France's Data Legal Drive (DLD Sapin II) in 2024.
34 / 58
Base 27 · Bonus 7 · Niveau P
Legal
7/16
Reporter
6/10
Handler
5/10
Security
5/8
Commercial
4/6
Forces
Packages page supports 80+ languages, anonymous dialogue, case management, deadline monitoring, telephone reporting on higher tiers, 2FA, and European hosting.
Security page supports ISO 27001, ISAE 3000 Type I/II, WACA Bronze, end-to-end encryption, no tracking, and Munich East data-centre disclosure.
Localized UK page publishes starting prices, so the prior fully quote-only claim was too broad.
Faiblesses
API access, public DPA, and subprocessor list were not disclosed on public pages reviewed. The UK packages FAQ claims the key is held by the customer, but the key-custody mechanism is not described further.
France Waserman/Sapin II and Greece Law 4990/2022 were not found on public pages reviewed.
Point distinctif
Integrity Line publishes package details and security/accessibility evidence; the UK packages FAQ states PGP 2048-bit RSA report encryption with the key in the customer's hand (vendor claim, 2026-10-24).
Lake Oswego, Oregon, United States · EthicsPoint hotline and WhistleB whistleblowing products within the NAVEX One GRC suite.
30 / 58
Base 27 · Bonus 3 · Niveau P
Legal
10/16
Reporter
5/10
Handler
6/10
Security
6/8
Commercial
0/6
Forces
Current whistleblowing page supports web and phone reporting, case tracking, anonymous reporting, AI-powered whistleblowing, and 13,000+/88M+ vendor scale claims.
WhistleB pages support ISO 27001, SOC 2 Type II, EU data storage, customer-controlled encryption, MFA, activity logs, Microsoft Azure hosting, Microsoft Translator localization, web and mobile reporting in 60+ languages and IVR in 40.
EthicsPoint service-hosting provider page is public and lists hosting, translation, interpretation, analytics, and platform service providers.
Faiblesses
EthicsPoint pricing, trial, API access, DPA, retention configuration, and Directive article-level mapping were not disclosed on public pages reviewed.
The Goldman Sachs Alternatives-led majority acquisition completed on 14 October 2025. The ISO 27001 certificate date and scope were not verified on vendor pages reviewed; the WhistleB page describes both ISO 27001 certification and ISO/IEC 27001-aligned practices.
Point distinctif
NAVEX publishes WhistleB security and EthicsPoint service-provider disclosures; current prices for both products require a quote.
Czech Republic · Whistleblowing, employee-relations, and workplace-compliance platform from the Czech Republic.
29 / 58
Base 28 · Bonus 1 · Niveau P
Legal
7/16
Reporter
7/10
Handler
5/10
Security
7/8
Commercial
2/6
Forces
Current public pricing page no longer exposes the previously captured EUR/GBP/USD/CZK employee-band amounts in the page output reviewed.
Public feature/pricing pages support 113 languages, anonymous reporting, two-way chat, online form, voice recording, automated/live/AI hotline add-ons, iOS/Android apps, multiple forms, webhooks, API, Zapier, and Make.
Security/DPA pages support ISO 27001:2022, SOC 2 hosting servers, optional E2EE, no IP storage, metadata removal, altered voice messages, SSO, 2FA, penetration testing, selectable AWS regions, subprocessor details, and OpenAI use limited to the AI-powered hotline.
Faiblesses
Pricing amounts were not found on the current public pricing page output reviewed.
Exact EU official-language list, article-by-article Directive mapping, Loi Waserman, Sapin II, and Greece Law 4990/2022 were not disclosed on public pages reviewed.
Point distinctif
FaceUp publishes security, DPA and integration information; prices and access to trial subscriptions require provider agreement.
West Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada · Live-answer ethics hotline and case management from WhistleBlower Security, a Case IQ company, with data held in Canada and sales-led pricing.
24 / 58
Base 23 · Bonus 1 · Niveau P
Legal
5/16
Reporter
7/10
Handler
9/10
Security
2/8
Commercial
0/6
Forces
Handler experience is the strongest category at 9 of 10: named case-scoped roles, multi-investigator assignment, automatic case routing, reporter-invisible internal messages, and a published case-state list.
Reporter intake is documented across four channels, with three anonymity levels and two-way anonymous messaging that continues after submission.
A full French locale of the marketing site exists and hotline agents directly support French, so a French reporter has a usable telephone route.
Faiblesses
Report data is held in Canada with no EU region offered, and the GDPR position rests on the Canadian adequacy decision rather than on a published DPA or sub-processor list.
No national transposition law is named on either locale of the site, and the EU Directive page still describes transposition and the 250-employee deadline as forthcoming.
Nothing is published on retention, automatic deletion, DPIA support, the 7-day acknowledgment deadline, or the 3-month feedback deadline.
Commercial disclosure scores 0 of 6: no price, no trial, no contract term.
Point distinctif
The vendor publishes its ISO 27001 certificate as a PDF rather than asserting the certification in prose, which is better practice than the NDA-only posture common in this market — and it is what makes the gap checkable. The certificate is against ISO/IEC 27001:2013 and expired on 31 October 2025, the end of the transition period to the 2022 edition. The certifications and trust-centre pages still say the company is ISO 27001 certified and maintains the certification with annual audits, but no newer certificate has been published in place of the expired one.
25 critères répartis en 5 catégories, pondérés par le nombre de critères. Chaque critère vaut 0, 1 ou 2 — affiché sous la forme ○ / ◐ / ●. Le score de base maximal est de 50. Les bonus spécifiques à France ajoutent jusqu’à 8 points par-dessus (modificateur, hors base).
Niveaux d’accès
Chaque outil porte un niveau d’accès qui reflète ce qui a réellement pu être testé :
P — pages publiques uniquement (marketing, prix, sécurité, URL signaleur).
P + R — idem, plus un test de dépôt de signalement.
P + R + H — idem, plus l’accès au tableau de bord handler / admin (via essai gratuit ou démo).
Les critères non vérifiables au niveau d’accès courant reçoivent 0 avec une ligne de preuve du type « Requires handler tier » ou « Not documented publicly ». Quand le score est déprimé par le niveau d’accès et non par la qualité produit, cela est signalé explicitement sur la fiche de l’outil.
Résidence des données
Tous les modificateurs pays notent la résidence de la même façon :
2 — Résidence des données dans le pays classé lui-même.
1 — Une résidence UE ou EEE est divulguée, mais pas dans le pays classé.
0 — Aucune résidence UE ou EEE n'est divulguée.
Garanties d’intégrité
Le barème a été figé avant le scoring. Aucun critère n’a été ajouté en cours de test pour favoriser ou pénaliser un outil précis.
Chaque score porte une preuve — URL, citation ou chemin de fichier — visible sur la fiche de l’outil.
Les outils opérés par l’éditeur du site sont notés avec le même barème. Le classement suit le score, pas l’inverse.
Chaque outil affiche une date de dernière revue et fait l’objet d’un re-test au moins annuel.
Les éditeurs peuvent contester un score ou soumettre la preuve d’un correctif livré via l’adresse de contact du site. Les contestations et mises à jour apparaissent comme des addenda datés sur la fiche concernée.
Droit appliqué
Loi n° 2022-401 du 21 mars 2022 (Loi Waserman) + Loi Sapin II pour les organisations de 500 salariés et plus (France, c’est-à-dire la transposition France de la directive UE 2019/1937). Les outils sont notés d’abord contre la directive, puis contre les spécificités du droit local.
Périmètre
Ce classement couvre 12 outils avec un bloc de scoring publié. D’autres outils seront ajoutés au fur et à mesure que leur scoring est finalisé. Les outils non scorés apparaîtront dans le classement une fois leur bloc publié.